Tonight I finally got back to Guitar Hero 3 and plowed through the Easy career in one sitting, mainly to get it out of the way early on, raise some easy cash, and unlock all of the songs for quick play. In fact, I earned enough to unlock all of the bonus songs and buy Slash as a character, since it was easy enough to five-star every song for the full reward. Except one song, that is — Raining Blood, which I could only three-star. It’s infamous for being near-impossible on the Expert level, and I’m not liking what I see of it already.

In fact, the difficulty of the songs didn’t always seem to match up with what tier they were in. Some of the later ones might have had more notes, but still felt a lot easier for some reason. I can’t remember which ones offhand though; I whipped through it so quickly that all the songs kind of blur together…

After completing Easy, I went back to Medium and tried the Tom Morello boss battle again. (I’d also played it while doing Easy, but it was no problem there.) I could keep up with the song this time, but still failed multiple times because it wasn’t clear just what was supposed to happen at the end of the song when ‘sudden death’ was supposed to kick in. I’d finish my part, Tom would play for a while, I’d get the ‘drain’ graphic on my side of the screen, and then I’d fail a few seconds later, without even having the chance to do anything since I never got any notes on my side while all that happened.

The game finally took pity on me and gave me an option to bow out and skip this battle, but I figured I was pretty close and kept trying. I finally beat him by holding on to a couple of attacks and saving them until that last section where Tom plays by himself for a while, and by using them all in a row, he failed fairly quickly. The boss battles are still annoying and pointless though, since they don’t really wind up having much to do with playing ability at all.

After that I went on to five-star the encore song, Bulls On Parade, so I’m definitely feeling some improvement. I then also tried a few of the bonus and download songs like Putting Holes In Happiness and The Pretender, and beat them on Medium, but not very well. PHiH is full of a really awkward, rapid transition between green and red single notes and chords, and The Pretender has a lot of hand-shifting chord transitions that I’m still not good at yet, making it hard to keep a multiplier going.

Now to continue the rest of the Medium campaign…

I worked my way through the rest of the tiers in Guitar Hero 2 today, completing the Medium difficulty. I didn’t fail any of the songs, but it was definitely getting tougher near the end, and my overall score (especially in terms of stars and multipliers) was much lower on those. I didn’t do as badly on Free Bird as I expected, but damn, that solo goes on forever…

Next up I think I’ll do the Medium campaign in GH3 before coming back and trying Hard in GH2. And then Hard in GH3, and so on.

And now that I’ve unlocked all of the songs, there’s less pressure to try and move on to the next one, so I can start taking things a bit more leisurely and focus on practicing specific songs for a while. I found that a lot of my trouble was simply not knowing the songs. Knowing the beat because you’ve heard the song before is about the only way I’ve found to keep up on those long, repeated note sequences.

I ended the night with a couple more hours in Guitar Hero 2 and completed two more tiers on Medium, putting me exactly halfway through the campaign by the song counts. The difficulty seems to be increasing a bit, but fairly slowly. I’m still only three or four-starring most songs though, which is a bit discouraging when you hear people talk about how they just bought their first GH game but they were five-starring everything right off the bat so they just skipped straight to Expert… :P

Chord transitions are still throwing me off when they involve the blue fret, and I also have trouble when quickly jumping from green down to blue; my pinky seems to lose its place and I wind up hitting yellow instead. Red/blue chords are also a bit of a problem, as I have a bit of trouble quickly transitioning to them without also subconsciously moving my ring finger too and hitting yellow. One tip I’ve seen is that I should actually rest my index finger on the red fret instead and shift up to hit green, to avoid using the much weaker pinky finger. And it’ll probably help get used to shifting, which I’ll have to do eventually when the orange fret gets introduced anyway.

I also fiddled around with the bonus songs for a bit, and went back and made another attempt at “Push Push (Lady Lightning)” and beat it this time. I failed in the way-too-chaotic-for-me intro the first time around, but fortunately the rest of the song isn’t quite that hard once you get past it. On a lark, I also tried “X-Stream” in Hard mode and was amazed to actually beat it. I must have come close to failing a good half-dozen times though, saved only by a large number of repeated chord and note sections that were a bit easier. I found myself deliberately skipping some notes just to keep in position for the next chord section.

I also tried Jordan on Expert just for yucks, and made it to…4%.

My Guitar Hero 3 bundle and copy of Guitar Hero 2 finally arrived today. You know how sometimes people can pick something up and discover they’re a natural at it without any prior exposure or practice?

Well, that’s not me. :P Even the medium difficulty in GH3 is kicking my ass so far. In order to proceed past the second tier, you have to defeat Tom Morello in a ‘boss battle’, and I’m stuck on that right now. I also went and tried out GH2 for a bit and it’s medium difficulty is definitely a bit easier. My main problems right now seem to be with parts that wildly jump between the frets, where I just can’t keep up and get out of sync, and long sections of quickly repeated notes, where I just can’t get the right rhythm.

I left the careers at the second tier in both, but unlocked a few of the bonus songs out of curiosity, including the infamous Jordan. I actually did better on it (88%/4 stars) than I did on Trogdor (80%/3 stars), though again this is just on medium. My highest score so far (around 118k) is actually from one of these bonus songs, specifically the Freezepop one. And I actually managed to get the ‘perfect song’ achievement in GH3, though admittedly from when I was first fooling around at the Easy level…

As for the guitar itself, it works pretty well, with none of the problems some other people have had about the detachable neck being loose and the frets sometimes not working. The only quirk is that I pretty much have to hold it vertically straight up to trigger star power, though that might be intentional.

And, as the title implies, my arms are already sore. I have to get into the habit of holding the frets properly; by default, I put too much pressure when pushing on it and my hand cramps up fairly quickly. I also still have to adjust the straps to hold it properly while standing, as proper rocking out does not involve sitting. And there’s already a slight bruise on my right arm from where it lies against the edge of the base…

Edit: Oh, and you can even follow along on my stats page at the official site.